YourMembership is an all-in-one AMS for small-staff associations. Pelcro is built around membership revenue and fulfillment.
YourMembership combines membership, events, community and dashboards, with add-ons for learning, careers and integrations. Pelcro brings dues billing, renewals, member access, and fulfillment into a single platform.
By submitting your email, you agree to opt in to marketing emails.
Where YourMembership and Pelcro differ
YourMembership has served small and mid-sized associations for more than 25 years. These are the main differences for associations focused on dues, access and fulfillment.
Integrations sold as add-ons
- YourMembership
- YourMembership lists its REST API and QuickBooks Connector as add-ons.
- Pelcro
- Pelcro includes integrations on every plan, and APIs and webhooks on the Advanced plan and above.
Failed payment recovery
- YourMembership
- YourMembership advertises recurring payments and automatic invoices; failed-payment recovery is not advertised.
- Pelcro
- Pelcro retries soft declines every 3, 5 or 7 days, up to 5 attempts, and sends Payment Failed emails.
Some reviewers report slow support responses
- YourMembership
- Some Capterra reviewers report waiting days or longer for support ticket responses. YourMembership's overall Capterra rating is 3.8 from 175 reviews.
Side-by-side comparison
Pelcro vs YourMembership, capability by capability
Pelcro brings dues billing, renewals, member access, and fulfillment into one platform.
| Capability | Pelcro | YourMembership |
|---|---|---|
AI Studio
| Yes | No |
Membership & Product Management
| Yes | Yes |
Billing & Payments
| Yes | Partial |
Access & UX
| Yes | Partial |
Fulfillment & Print
| Yes | Partial |
Data & Reporting
| Yes | Yes |
Automation & Integrations
| Yes | Partial |
Services & Support
| Yes | No |
Pelcro AI Studio
Skip the separate website builder
Describe the member site or page you want. Pelcro AI Studio writes valid Pelcro code, opens a branch, and hands you a preview link to approve — no separate website builder to buy or maintain.
Example prompt
“Build a membership site with sign-up, checkout, and a member login”
No separate website builder
Scaffold member sign-up, checkout, billing, and login pages from a prompt, wired to Pelcro from the first commit.
No engineering ticket
Launch a new membership page without waiting on a deploy window or a developer's backlog.
Keep the site you already run
Already on WordPress? The agent reads your theme and adds Pelcro where it belongs.
Every change is reviewable
Changes are ordinary code on a branch with a preview link. Rollback is one click.
The future of association management is here
Run dues, renewals, and member access from one modern unified system
- SubscribersPrint + digital5,836+4.2% this monthAll Access — Digital + Print1,284Print · Daily delivery642Digital · Monthly3,910
Manage every member from one dashboard
Issue refunds, view dues invoices and fulfillments, all from one single source of truth.
See all comparisons - Invoice #4821PaidAll Access · Monthly$24.00Print delivery$7.00Total$31.00Auto-collected · Visa ·· 4242Reconciled
Automate dues invoicing, accounts receivable, and payable
Automate recurring dues billing and renewals to save yourself and your team time.
See all comparisons
TeddyMy accountAll Access — Digital + PrintActiveRenews Aug 1 · $31.00/moUpdate cardInvoicesOffer seamless member experiences with self-serve portals
Let members manage their memberships, invoices, payment methods and profiles in their portal to improve experiences and reduce member support inquiries.
See all comparisons
Migration made easy
Switching from YourMembership shouldn't take months to implement
Pelcro doesn't just provide software — we provide hands-on support for your entire membership operation. From onboarding and migrations to member support and fulfillment, our team ensures a smooth transition without disrupting your association.
Talk to our teamAn honest take
When YourMembership may be the better fit
Pelcro isn't the right choice for every team. YourMembership may suit you better if one of these describes your situation.
You want event management with badge printing built in
YourMembership lets you create, host and manage events and print event badges directly from the AMS.
Source: yourmembership.com: features (opens in a new tab)You want a built-in online community
YourMembership includes an online community with built-in engagement scoring.
Source: yourmembership.com: features (opens in a new tab)You want learning and career center add-ons from one vendor
YourMembership offers Learning Management System and Job Board Software add-ons.
Source: yourmembership.com: offerings (opens in a new tab)You want website design services from your AMS vendor
YourMembership offers website design services.
Source: yourmembership.com: offerings (opens in a new tab)
Pelcro vs YourMembership: frequently asked questions
Last updated: . Claims about YourMembership were checked against YourMembership's own website on that date.
Does YourMembership include event management?
Yes. YourMembership lets you create, host and manage events, including printing event badges. Pelcro does not advertise event management; it focuses on dues billing, renewals, member access and fulfillment.
Does YourMembership handle print fulfillment?
Not as an advertised feature. Its print feature is event badges, and a CASS with Political Districting Bundle add-on is listed without a description. Pelcro includes fulfillment lists, mailroom exports and CASS-certified USPS address verification with the codes used for USPS presort rates.
Does YourMembership have an API?
Yes, as an add-on: YourMembership lists a REST API among its add-on offerings, along with a QuickBooks Connector. Pelcro includes integrations on all plans.
Does YourMembership publish pricing?
No. YourMembership does not publish pricing on its site and asks you to book a demo. Pelcro publishes a free plan for up to 100 customers, Advanced at $450 per month, Professional at $800 per month and custom Enterprise plans.
Can I migrate from YourMembership to Pelcro?
Yes. Pelcro includes an import tool on all plans, and Pelcro Professional Services can migrate user data and subscriptions, with limits that may apply by plan. There are no setup fees unless you ask Pelcro's team to handle migrations, customizations or integrations.
Get started
See why associations choose Pelcro over YourMembership
Book a 30-minute walkthrough and we will map the platform to your specific requirements.
By submitting your email, you agree to opt in to marketing emails.